Element 68Element 45Element 44Element 63Element 64Element 43Element 41Element 46Element 47Element 69Element 76Element 62Element 61Element 81Element 82Element 50Element 52Element 79Element 79Element 7Element 8Element 73Element 74Element 17Element 16Element 75Element 13Element 12Element 14Element 15Element 31Element 32Element 59Element 58Element 71Element 70Element 88Element 88Element 56Element 57Element 54Element 55Element 18Element 20Element 23Element 65Element 21Element 22iconsiconsElement 83iconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsiconsElement 84iconsiconsElement 36Element 35Element 1Element 27Element 28Element 30Element 29Element 24Element 25Element 2Element 1Element 66
Enforcement of Rules in the Context of Community-Involved Social Media Platforms - User Courts and Other Participation Formats as Stabilising Moments of Ownership

Enforcement of Rules in the Context of Community-Involved Social Media Platforms - User Courts and Other Participation Formats as Stabilising Moments of Ownership

Close community cooperation and increased identification with the platform often promote mechanisms in which communities actively adopt and enforce the rules that come from these platforms ("ownership"). This project will explore the relationship between identification with the platform, community participation and the enforcement of rules. The perspective of platforms, especially small and niche platforms and their community areas will be included. Exemplary user courts from the 2000s of the internet, but also the Wikipedia arbitration court will be examined.

Research questions:
  • What types of community identification and participation exist and to what extent do they support the development and enforcement of rule-making?
  • What role does ownership play in this? How can this be described?
  • What kind of decision-making structures about rule-making exist (e.g. user courts), what do they look like, how "democratic" are they?
We will survey those platforms, which have already been contacted in the platform governance project during the super election year 2021. The focus is on the impact of their community work in terms of "ownership". This type of "ownership" is described as an identification; a concept that the study would like to bring together with the offers of community participation and survey it qualitatively. There are a variety of participation formats, such as user courts, "superuser status", trusted flaggers and arbitration courts, which enable participation.
  • To what extent do these forms of pre-institutionalisation promote a high level of identification and commitment with the platform itself?
  • Do they support the enforcement of norms or generate dissent from existing community rules of the platform?
  • To what extent do they stabilise the moments of identification and "ownership" of a platform?
  • When and how are the rules binding with the (private-entrepreneurial) platform?
  • How relevant is the cooperation with the platform itself?
Answering these questions will provide a first overview of the development of ownership on community-involved social media platforms and thus bring new perspectives to the existing research on communities.

In this way, the study should contribute to the academic debate with niche communication spaces and other alternative digital and public spaces as experimental fields of a democratic-oriented practice.
Image: Engraving of Gilbert and Sullivan's Trial by Jury.
show more

Project Description

Findings will follow soon.

Project Information


Duration: 2022-2022

Research programme:
RP2 - Regulatory Structures and the Emergence of Rules in Digital Communication

Third party

Seed Money

Cooperation Partner

Studentische Mitarbeiterinnen: Lena Hinrichs und Vivienne Gold

Contact person

Dipl.-Päd. Christina Dinar, M. A.
Junior Researcher Platform Governance

Dipl.-Päd. Christina Dinar, M. A.

Leibniz-Institut für Medienforschung | Hans-bredow-Institut
Rothenbaumchaussee 36
20148 Hamburg
Tel. +49 (0)40 450 21 7-0

Send Email



Subscribe to our newsletter and receive the Institute's latest news via email.